Sheepdog Training 15 – Started sheepdog or puppy?

Photo of Border Collie pup Rebus looking at a sheep

Should you buy a puppy or a started dog?

Are you choosing between a started sheepdog or a puppy? It’s a very long road from buying a puppy to taking part in your first trial, or gathering your flock. The idea of training your own dog can be daunting if you’re a novice handler, but if you buy a puppy you can be sure it hasn’t developed any bad habits. As training progresses there’s a real benefit to knowing the history of your dog. Understanding your dog’s previous experiences with sheep (good and bad) can help you understand any problems that arise.

Choosing between a started sheepdog or a puppy

Is a started dog a shortcut?

On the other hand, if you buy a started dog you could be working, even trialling, sooner, but the time difference is probably quite small. A puppy is usually available for sale at two months, and a started dog may be only 9 or 10 months old. Those early months can be well spent in getting to know your pup, creating a bond with it, and putting some early basic training in place.

Generally, you won’t go too far wrong if you follow some simple guidelines.


Buy from a good source of working stock, relevant to the type of work you need to do with the dog. Traditionally, Border collie puppies have been so cheap that you can buy a son or daughter of a Supreme International champion for only a few hundred pounds. The offspring of equally good dogs may cost slightly less, but don’t be fooled into believing that buying the son of a Supreme Champion will automatically produce a winner – it’s only a part of the story. Even if a pup has the potential to equal his sire or dam (and breeding often doesn’t work like that) the WORK is down to you – the trainer and handler. But buying from a good line will give you the best start.

Ask the seller if you can bring the dog or pup back for a full refund within a certain period of time (we suggest 30 days) if it proves unsuitable or you don’t like it.

Visit some started dogs

If you can afford more than puppy prices, and like the idea of a started dog, go to view some. Watch the dog working. Try to spend some time with it away from the sheep, and if you like it and it seems keen but controllable, buy it. DON’T buy it because you can return it – it isn’t fair on either the dog or the buyer. If you buy the dog, commit to the dog. And sign up to our online tutorials! A started dog will be just that, so make the best start you can, and make haste slowly.

Who ever met a puppy they didn’t like? If you decide on a puppy the choice is wider but arguably more difficult. Meet the parents, meet the breeder, and if you feel you like them all then buy a puppy. If you have any reservations about the parents or the breeder then say thank you politely and move on.

Just pick the prettiest?

It’s difficult to choose a life partner from only one visit. Common sense says don’t choose the cutest just because it’s the cutest – looks aren’t everything. Don’t necessarily buy the puppy who “chooses you” – the chances are it “chooses” everyone because it’s naturally bold and outgoing. This strong character could prove to be a dominant dog as it matures, and it will be just the dog that someone wants and needs. It won’t be the easiest dog for a novice handler. The puppy that cowers in the corner when it sees a stranger might be one to avoid, but how does it respond to its breeder? It may not fawn over newcomers but will forge a strong bond to become a loyal companion, worker and a team player.

You may find yourself tempted by an older dog. Bear in mind there’s always a reason why someone is selling any dog, whether fully or partly trained. However this doesn’t have to be a bad thing.

A difficult dog for one handler can be a trial winner in different hands. Just as with any partnership, personalities can clash. A change of owner, a change of regime and a fresh approach can bring out its best.

CLEAR, AFFORDABLE SHEEP AND CATTLE DOG TRAINING INSTRUCTION

Over 70 clearly explained, easy to follow sheep and cattle dog training videos for first time sheepdog trainers, farmers, and shepherds. Just £12 per month or £120 per year (choice of currencies for payment). Watch the preview here!

For French, Spanish or English SUBTITLES click “CC” on player.

video
play-sharp-fill

For a very small monthly (or annual) subscription, watch many hours of expertly presented sheepdog training lessons. Not just theory – we show you what should happen, and what to do when things go wrong. Signup now. It’s easy to cancel payments at any time and you can continue to watch for the period you paid for.

Pay for your membership with VISA
Pay for your membership with MASTERCARD
Pay for your membership with AMERICAN EXPRESS
Pay for your membership with your DISCOVER card
Pay for your Membership with PayPal
Securely powered by STRIPE

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *