A sheepdog can have psychological issues too

Training a sheepdog isn’t always as straightforward as you’d think

Nell is a rough coated tri-coloured female border collie sheepdog with psychological issues
Nell’s a good looking dog and she’s very keen to work sheep, but she has issues.

Nell’s our latest work in progress. She’s been here for four weeks now, is desperate to work and showing power with sheep, but she’s quite terrified of strangers.

When she first came to us she showed all the usual signs of a very nervous dog, pulling back on her lead and then (if she had no other choice) shooting through a gap as though the very devil were after her. Of course, these actions in themselves can compound the dog’s fear – especially when it shoots through the gap so fast that it swings by its neck as it reaches the end of the lead.

When I first saw her I suspected that poor Nell’s nervousness meant she’d spent a great deal of time being extremely bored. The scabs and lack of fur on the end of her tail (caused by chewing) were testament to that, but after she’d been here for a few hours we noticed an even more worrying habit. Her previous owner hadn’t mentioned Nell’s habit of walking around in anticlockwise circles when she’s bored or stressed.

Fortunately, keeping Nell occupied with regular training on sheep, housing her in a pen alongside other dogs, and taking her out for regular runs with everybody has reduced the circling considerably. At first we couldn’t let Nell run free with the other dogs because she’d run off to the sheep, so when we took all the dogs out for their twice-daily run, we put Nell on a rope and attached it to the branch of a tree so that she could move around without getting tangled or wrapping the rope around the tree trunk. Then we’d play with the dogs close-by, in the hope that Nell would take an interest.

Gill gives Nell some fuss while the rest of the dogs look on
Gill gives Nell some “quality” time as the other dogs look on.

At first Nell just lay down and looked dejected. Sometimes the younger members of the pack would pester her by playing tug with the rope, but Nell showed no interest. After a few days, though, much retrieving of frisbees and balls, and the accompanying excitement shown by the other dogs, attracted Nell’s attention and she started to socialise with them a little. We found that if we attached her to the rope, but left the other end free, Nell stayed around reasonably well. At first she kept her distance and observed but, occasionally, she’d come closer to the others for a while before retiring to a “safe” distance again.

Occasionally we had to retrieve her from the fence between the main part of the field and the paddock where the sheep are. Fortunately, she didn’t jump over the fence so she couldn’t chase the sheep, but she’d run up and down the fence and wouldn’t come back if we called her. It was a bit tiresome but, eventually, she wandered off less frequently and even began to come back when we called her.

At last, we feel we’re making progress. Nell’s much more obedient and will actually come to Gill for attention when they’re in the field or the yard, and will even jump up to her but (possibly because I’m male) she won’t come up to me yet. She clearly wants to though – she comes to within a metre but no touching yet! It’s just a matter of time and patience. The best way to get a nervous dog to come to you is to ignore it, so that’s the stage Nell and I are at just at the moment.

Socializing a nervous sheepdog - Nell submits to Gill
In the early days – Nell submits and allows Gill to approach her.

Her sheep work is improving rapidly. At first, Nell was aggressive with the sheep, refused to go clockwise, and used her anticlockwise flanks as a form of distraction by going absurdly wide and refusing to stop. This meant she completely lost control of the sheep on occasions, but regular training has improved her no end. The aggression is all but gone and although she still doesn’t like going clockwise, she will do it. The anticlockwise flanks are becoming more sensible too. Nell’s stopped biting her tail and the scabs have healed. Occasionally she’ll circle when it’s close to the time we take the dogs out, but it’s nothing much, and she’ll stop if we tell her to.

Even though she won’t come to me in the field, I feel there’s mutual trust building between us. Now that she’s no longer on a rope when she goes out into the field with the other dogs, Nell will sometimes wander up to the sheep paddock and have a look at them, but she can be trusted to come back on her own, and usually comes straight away when called. Progress indeed! Soon she’ll make a really good sheepdog – for the right owner.




Watch Pearl Glen, Mel and lots of the dogs you saw in our first DVD Border Collie Sheepdogs – Off Duty! PLUS MANY MORE! The DVD is available from our DVD Store – and we automatically ship the correct format for your country. More info.


3 responses to “A sheepdog can have psychological issues too”

  1. Muriel Naughton avatar
    Muriel Naughton

    Our new dog Poppy spent the first year of her life mainly in kennels on a remote Welsh sheep farm. Although she suffered no abuse she wasn’t socialised except with the farm pack of dogs. Consequently she too is frightened of everything (also wary of men, particularly in hats) and has occasional outbursts of nervous aggression towards other dogs. She too loves working sheep and is showing great potential, fortunately she has good recall. I’d love to hear more of Nell’s progress and any tips on integrating adult dogs would be gratefully received. Poppy is having trouble accepting Mother-in-law’s dog which is a little awkward!

    1. Hello Muriel,
      You don’t say how long you’ve had Poppy or how old she is. Hopefully the aggression she shows towards your mother in law’s dog will settle down as the dog’s confidence grows. Nell’s improving daily.
      In our experience, the more training the dog has on sheep, and the more time it spends with its owner during the day, the better its general behaviour.

      1. Muriel Naughton avatar
        Muriel Naughton

        Sorry, lack of detail supplied. We have had Poppy two months, we were told she was about a year old but obviously that is very vague, she had her first heat soon after arriving with us probably as her general fitness and condition improved. Unfortunately her season certainly didn’t help the settling in process or the work needed to get her more socialised! However, we’re through that and making progress with most things.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *